*Note: What is an AMWAP review? It’s a thing I made up. It stands for “As Many Words as Pages.” My AMWAP book reviews are uniquely crafted towards a specific word count. It’s my little way of keeping things snappy and driving myself slowly insane.For instance…The following book review is 309 words long.
Here on Earth
Last night I finished reading Alice Hoffman’s Here on Earth (1997). In case you are unacquainted with her, Hoffman’s got this raw-but-lyrical quality that leaves you feeling like you’ve been emotionally stripped bare at some kind of intervention, but that (somehow) you were thoroughly enchanted by the entire experience. It’s fitting that she often writes about magic, because her stories are spellbinding.
Recently, Here on Earth caught my eye. I read a New York Times Book Review that called it, “a Wuthering Heights . . . profound.” Sadistic though it may be, I’ve always loved Emily Bronte’s twisted love story and the way it makes prickle with goosebumps of anger, passion, and regret.
And that’s pretty much the exact same effect of Hoffman’s Here on Earth.
The story successfully carries the haunting themes of Wuthering Heights into a setting of 1990s America as it follows the return of March Murray to her small hometown. When March re-encounters Hollis, the childhood love she never let go of, the passionate bond between them grows. As their relationship illuminates the ghosts of their common past, it also begins to cast a destructive shadow over their lives. Despite the absence of Bronte’s moors, the rural Massachusetts setting of Here on Earth carries a ghostly mystique of its own.
Though I openly recommended this book to everyone while still in its early chapters, I would be more selective in my recommendations having finished it. Literary triumph? Definitely. Disturbing? Definitely. Just don’t tell your teenager to read this alongside Wuthering Heights, okay?
Overall, Here on Earth is a choice autumnal read for those who know what they are in for: a dark and compelling re-imagining. It poses some pretty interesting questions about romantic possession, redemption, revenge and what might have happened if Catherine and Heathcliff had gotten a chance to be together, “here on earth.”